What according to the Supreme Court constitutes "the basic structure" of our constitution? Please name a…

Question

What according to the Supreme Court constitutes "the basic structure" of our constitution? Please name a couple of important judgements of the Supreme Court on this issue?

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

The Supreme Court holds that Parliament cannot amend away the Constitution's basic structure, which includes constitutional supremacy, democracy, secularism, federalism, separation of powers, judicial review, rule of law and fundamental rights. Key judgments are Kesavananda Bharati (1973), Minerva Mills (1980), the Bommai case (1994) and the Coelho case (2007).

**Introduction**

The basic structure doctrine, crystallized in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), restricts Parliament’s power to amend the Constitution’s core framework, safeguarding democratic, secular, and federal principles essential to India’s constitutional identity.

**Judicial Foundations**

1. **Kesavananda Bharati Case⟦1⟧**: The Supreme Court identified essential features like supremacy of the Constitution, secularism, federalism, separation of powers, and unity of the nation as inviolable, limiting Parliament’s amending power.

2. **Key Features**: Judicial review, rule of law, independence of judiciary, parliamentary system, fundamental rights, and socio-economic justice are integral parts of the basic structure that preserve constitutional spirit.

**Subsequent Clarifications**

3. **Important Judgments**: Minerva Mills (1980) reinforced the balance between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles; S.R. Bommai (1994) emphasized federalism and secularism; I.R. Coelho (2007) upheld judicial review over Ninth Schedule laws, affirming the doctrine’s continuing relevance.

4. **Judicial Role and Challenges**: The Supreme Court acts as guardian of the basic structure through judicial review but the wider judiciary carries heavy pendency, with around 1.82 lakh cases pending for over 30 years in High Courts and district courts, which delays constitutional adjudication and affects timely enforcement of constitutional principles.

**Way Forward**

5. **Clearer Guidelines**: The Court should articulate a more precise framework for identifying the basic structure to reduce ambiguity and enhance predictability in constitutional amendments.

6. **Judicial Strengthening**: Addressing judicial vacancies, including 371 vacancies in High Courts, and reducing delays will improve the judiciary’s capacity to uphold the basic structure effectively and ensure timely justice.

**Conclusion**

The doctrine protects India’s constitutional identity and democratic ethos, ensuring the Constitution remains a living document that balances flexibility with the preservation of core principles amid evolving political and social challenges.

Model answer

ఈ ప్రశ్నను ప్రాక్టీస్ చేయండి

భారత రాజ్యాంగం, ప్రాథమిక హక్కులు, DPSP మరియు కేంద్ర-రాష్ట్ర విధులు18 questions

Ghissu