Critically examine different models of secularism in India.

Question

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

India has three models of secularism: principled distance, where the state may reform religious practice under Article 25; equal respect (sarva dharma sambhava); and a strict Western wall of separation. Principled distance applied consistently with equal respect suits India best, and SR Bommai made secularism part of the basic structure.

**Introduction**

India’s secularism, central to its constitutional identity, manages religious diversity through distinct models reflecting its pluralistic society.

**Models of Secularism**

1. **Principled Distance Model**: Permits state intervention in religion to reform harmful practices, grounded in Article 25 and exemplified by the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act (2019).  
2. **Equal Respect Model (Sarva Dharma Sambhava)**: Emphasizes equal respect for all religions, with state support for religious events like the Kumbh Mela (the Haj subsidy ended in 2018), reflecting India’s inclusive ethos.

**Critical Evaluation**

1. **Principled Distance**: Balances religious freedom⟦1⟧ and social reform but risks perceptions of bias and communal backlash, as in the Karnataka hijab dispute.  
2. **Equal Respect**: Encourages social cohesion but criticized for fostering “pseudo-secularism” and vote-bank politics, undermining neutrality.

**Practical Challenges**

1. **Religious Diversity and Communalism**: Rising majoritarianism and fundamentalism threaten secularism’s core, with communal riots and politicization of religion increasing.  
2. **Legal Complexities**: Personal laws and the Uniform Civil Code debate complicate secular application; ==Telangana’s== post-statehood communal harmony shows regional sensitivities.  
3. **Political Exploitation**: Secularism’s accommodation models are vulnerable to vote-bank politics, deepening divides and undermining constitutional morality.  
4. **Judicial Role**: Courts balance religious freedom and social justice, as in the Shirur Mutt and Sabarimala cases, but face resistance from conservative groups.

**Way Forward**

1. **Strengthen Constitutional Morality**: Promote fraternity and equality through education and discourse.  
2. **Enhance Principled Intervention**: Develop transparent, consultative state mechanisms sensitive to community sentiments.

**Conclusion**

India’s secularism models reflect its pluralism but require vigilant protection against communalism and political misuse to uphold constitutional values.

భారతదేశంలో లౌకికవాదం (secularism) యొక్క వివిధ నమూనాలను విమర్శనాత్మకంగా పరిశీలించండి.

Model answer

ఈ ప్రశ్నను ప్రాక్టీస్ చేయండి

సామాజిక సమస్యలు: పేదరికం, నిరుద్యోగం, మతతత్వం, అవినీతి, వలసలు2 questions

Ghissu