Did the Government of India Act, 1935 lay down a federal constitution ? Discuss.

Question

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

The Government of India Act, 1935 laid down a federal constitution in form but not in substance, since Governor-General overrides, Westminster supremacy and voluntary accession kept it unitary. Its federal part never came into force because too few princely states acceded before suspension in 1939.

**Introduction**

K.C. Wheare tests a federation by whether the Centre and the units are coordinate and independent in their own spheres. Measured so, the Government of India Act, 1935 gave India a federal form around a unitary core.

**Federal Features Written into the 1935 Act**

1. **All-India Federation**: It proposed a Federation of British provinces and princely states under one constitution, the first attempt to bind both Indias together.
2. **Three-List Division**: Powers were split into Federal (59), Provincial (54) and Concurrent (36) Lists, the ancestor of the Seventh Schedule.
3. **Provincial Autonomy**: Dyarchy ended in the provinces, and elected ministries governed their own subjects from 1937, with Congress ministries in most provinces.
4. **Federal Court**: Set up in 1937, it was given original jurisdiction over disputes between the units, the umpire every federation needs.

**Unitary Controls that Hollowed the Federation**

1. **Governor-General's Overrides**: Discretion, special responsibilities, ordinances and the residuary power (Section 104) let the Governor-General legislate on his own and override ministers, so the Centre was never merely coordinate.
2. **Section 93 Takeover**: Governors took over provinces in 1939 after Congress ministries resigned.
3. **Westminster Supremacy**: Only the British Parliament could amend the Act, and appeals went to the Privy Council.
4. **Federation that Never Came**: Accession was voluntary, too few princes joined, and the federal part was suspended in 1939.

SKETCH: spectrum | Where the 1935 Act Sits
left: Unitary
right: Federal
- 1919 Act dyarchy
- 1935 Act
- 1950 Constitution
- USA 1787

**Conclusion**

The Act was federal on paper, not in practice; Nehru called it a machine with strong brakes and no engine. Its real legacy was the blueprint of lists, Federal Court and emergency powers that the 1950 Constitution adopted.

Did the Government of India Act, 1935 lay down a federal constitution ? Discuss.

Model answer

Practise this question

Issues & Challenges Pertaining to the Federal Structure5 questions

Ghissu