Evaluate the policies of Lord Curzon and their long term implications on the national movements.

Question

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

Curzon's efficiency-driven but centralising policies, above all the 1905 partition of Bengal, backfired by radicalising Indian nationalism. The Swadeshi movement, the Surat split, revolutionary groups and the Muslim League's founding in 1906 followed, though his Ancient Monuments Preservation Act (1904) was a lasting gain.

**Introduction**

Lord Curzon (1899-1905) sought to make British rule efficient and permanent, yet, as Sumit Sarkar shows, his tenure radicalised Indian nationalism more than any other. His record must be judged on both administrative and political scales.

**Curzon's Policies: Efficiency with an Imperial Edge**

1. **Curbs on self-government**: The Calcutta Corporation Act (1899) cut elected members and the Official Secrets Act (1904) restricted the press.
2. **Control of universities**: The Indian Universities Act (1904), after the Raleigh Commission, tightened official control and alienated the educated middle class.
3. **Partition of Bengal**: Effected in October 1905, it was seen by Risley as a way to divide a united, politically conscious Bengal.
4. **Constructive reforms**: The Ancient Monuments Preservation Act (1904), the Pusa research institute and the Police Commission (1902) were lasting gains.

**Long-term Implications for the National Movement**

SKETCH: comparison | Curzon's Intent vs Outcome
a: Intent
b: Outcome
- Weaken Bengal :: Bengal united in protest
- Contain Congress :: Congress radicalised
- Control the educated :: Educated alienated
- Divide communities :: Communal politics seeded

1. **Swadeshi as rehearsal**: Boycott, national education and swadeshi enterprise became techniques Gandhi later scaled up.
2. **Extremism and revolution**: The swaraj goal (1906), the Surat split (1907) and groups such as the Anushilan Samiti followed as Tilak and Aurobindo gained ground.
3. **Communal politics**: The Muslim League (Dacca, 1906) and separate electorates (1909) seeded religious politics that ran on to 1947.
4. **Confidence of victory**: The annulment of 1911 showed that agitation could reverse imperial decisions.

**Conclusion**

Curzon succeeded as an administrator but failed as a strategist; Gokhale likened his rule to Aurangzeb's. A viceroy who sought to secure the Raj became the unwitting catalyst of mass nationalism and of the communal divide.

Evaluate the policies of Lord Curzon and their long term implications on the national movements.

Model answer

Practise this question

Role of Masses and Personalities13 questions

Ghissu