The Finance Commission, though not being a permanent body, has still maintained its credibility by…

Question

The Finance Commission, though not being a permanent body, has still maintained its credibility by promoting fiscal democracy in India' — Comment.

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

Though constituted afresh every five years with only advisory powers, the Finance Commission has kept its credibility through expert composition, quasi-judicial impartiality, evolving normative methods and near-routine government acceptance of its reports. By sharing resources fairly with states and local bodies, it has promoted fiscal democracy in India.

**Introduction**

The Finance Commission⟦1⟧, established under Article 280, is a non-permanent body appointed every five years to recommend financial resource sharing between the Union and states. Despite its temporary status, it has maintained credibility and promoted fiscal democracy, addressing complex fiscal challenges including those faced by ==Andhra Pradesh⟦4⟧⟦3⟧⟦2⟧== post-bifurcation.

**Non-Permanent Status and Implications**

1. **Ad Hoc Constitution**: The Commission’s five-year tenure allows flexibility to address evolving fiscal realities but can delay resource allocation, impacting states like ==Andhra Pradesh==, which faced delayed revenue deficit grants.

**Credibility Maintenance**

1. **Quasi-Judicial Impartiality**: Article 280 mandates impartiality, earning trust as a neutral arbiter; the Fifteenth Finance Commission⟦5⟧’s COVID-19 report was largely implemented, showing sustained respect.

2. **Balancing Regional Concerns**: It considers population, income, and fiscal discipline, addressing states’ demands, including ==Andhra Pradesh==’s special category status and fiscal pressures.

**Promotion of Fiscal Democracy**

1. **Equitable Resource Distribution**: Tax devolution and grants empower states financially, promoting decentralization.

2. **Strengthening Local Governments**: Post-73rd and 74th Amendments, the Commission supports Panchayats and Municipalities, vital for inclusive development in rural ==Andhra Pradesh==.

3. **Performance-Based Incentives**: Recent grants incentivize governance improvements, fostering accountability.

4. **Implementation Challenges**: ==Andhra Pradesh== audits reveal revenue and compliance gaps⟦6⟧ limiting fiscal autonomy, constraining full fiscal democracy.

**Way Forward**

1. **Institutional Continuity**: A permanent secretariat could ensure timely implementation.

2. **Binding Recommendations**: Legal backing would reduce political arbitrariness.

3. **Enhanced State Consultations**: Greater engagement with states like ==Andhra Pradesh== would reflect regional realities better.

**Conclusion**

The Finance Commission, despite its non-permanent status, maintains credibility and promotes fiscal democracy by balancing equity and regional concerns.

The Finance Commission, though not being a permanent body, has still maintained its credibility by promoting fiscal democracy in India' — Comment.

Model answer

Practise this question

Local governance (73rd/74th) and Constitutional Authorities13 questions

Ghissu