Give instances wherein the Constitution provides control of the Union over the States.

Question

Ghissu Editorial · Accepted Answer

The Constitution gives the Union legislative, administrative, financial and emergency control over States, including Union law prevailing under Article 254, Parliament legislating on State subjects under Article 249 and binding directions under Articles 256 and 257. Under Article 356, the Union can impose President's Rule when state constitutional machinery fails.

**Introduction**

The Indian Constitution creates a federal system with a unitary bias, granting the Union significant control over States to ensure national unity and uniform governance, as seen in ==Polavaram== and inter-state river disputes involving ==Krishna and Godavari waters==. This balance is crucial to manage diversity and maintain policy coherence across States.

**Constitutional Provisions Granting Union Control Over States**

1. **Legislative Supremacy via Seventh Schedule**: Parliament exclusively controls the Union List and residuary subjects (Article 248); Union law overrides State law on Concurrent List conflicts (Article 254), ensuring central legislative dominance.

2. **Emergency Provisions Enabling Central Override**: Articles 352, 356, and 360 empower the Union to impose President’s Rule during crises, exemplified by ==Andhra Pradesh’s President’s Rule episodes==. These provisions allow temporary suspension of State autonomy to restore constitutional order.

**Nature and Scope of Union Control Mechanisms**

4. **Parliament’s Power to Legislate on State Subjects**: Article 249 allows Parliament to legislate on State List matters with Rajya Sabha’s two-thirds resolution in national interest. This extends Union legislative reach during critical situations.

**Implications for Centre-State Relations**

5. **Centralisation vs. State Autonomy Tension**: The Union’s overriding powers often cause friction, as seen in ==Andhra Pradesh’s bifurcation and demands for autonomy==. States frequently seek greater fiscal and administrative independence.

6. **Financial Control and Fiscal Dependence**: Union controls major taxes and grants (Articles 268-293); ==Andhra Pradesh’s demand for Special Category Status== highlights fiscal tensions. The Finance Commission’s recommendations mediate resource sharing but do not eliminate disputes.

**Conclusion**

Union control provisions maintain national integrity but risk over-centralisation, necessitating cooperative federalism and institutional reforms to balance Centre-State relations. Strengthening bodies like the Inter-State Council and reforming emergency provisions can enhance mutual trust and governance.

Give instances wherein the Constitution provides control of the Union over the States.

Model answer

Practise this question

Federal structure, Governor and distribution of powers17 questions

Ghissu